The Cardinal Nation blog

Brian Walton's news and commentary on the St. Louis Cardinals (TM) and their minor league system

TCN Blog 2012 Cardinals top story #8: Berkman’s fade

Though it can never be proven, I suspect the absence of Lance Berkman may have been the single biggest blow absorbed by the 2012 St. Louis Cardinals – even greater than the comparable loss of Chris Carpenter. Berkman missing all but 32 games caused an impact on the payroll, the results on the field and in the clubhouse.

In September 2011, when the Cardinals re-signed Berkman to his second consecutive one-year contract, my first reaction was that the move was a hedge against the offense that could be lost by the then-potential departure of free agent-to-be Albert Pujols.

My next thought was that the organization may have been rewarding Berkman for a tremendous 2011 that would culminate in he and his teammates winning the World Series. Berkman was a National League all-star, and following the season, he was deservedly named NL Comeback Player of the Year.

Only later when manager Tony La Russa and Pujols joined the ranks of ex-Cardinals did I fully consider the depth of a potential leadership void – one which a healthy and productive Berkman seemed ideal to help fill.

One could argue whether it should have been an expectation or merely a hope that the oft-injured 36-year-old would replicate his 2011 offensive results somehow. Either way, he was given an increase in salary from $8 million in 2011 to $12 million in 2012.

One line of thinking was that moving from the outfield in 2011 back to first base in 2012 would help Berkman remain healthier. That was proven to not be the case. He not only had three long stints on the disabled list, he left the club several times for surgery and recovery.

Berkman played in just seven games in April before injuring a calf muscle and hitting the DL. He returned in May, appearing in just six games this time, before hurting his right knee again.

Though he pushed for his mid-July activation, Berkman’s knee was still not right. He made just nine starts and a half-dozen pinch-hitting appearances before being shut down again on August 2.

The switch-hitter was activated when rosters expanded on September 1, but after just three games, his ongoing knee problems led to yet another surgery.

After hitting 31 home runs in 2011, he finished with just two in 2012. Berkman made 97 plate appearances in 32 games and batted .259. He was unable to participate in the post-season.

The Cardinals gave Berkman a courtesy at-bat in their final regular-season game on October 3. That may or may not have concluded his long and successful career, but it certainly ended his time with St. Louis, as the club did not invite him back for 2013.

Link to The Cardinal Nation Blog’s top 20 stories of the year countdown

Follow me on Twitter.
Follow The Cardinal Nation Blog on Facebook.

4 Responses to “TCN Blog 2012 Cardinals top story #8: Berkman’s fade”

  1. JumboShrimp says:

    One of Mo’s tactics has been to sign post-peak veterans to short term deals in hopes of squeezing some more good performance out of them. Qualifiers include Berkman, Furcal, Chris Carpenter, Beltran, Westbrook, Choate, Romero, Rhodes, Wigginton. Sometimes this works out, sometimes it does not.

    • JumboShrimp says:

      JC Romero, Brian Fuentes, and LHP Tallet are three more examples of gambles with older players that did not pan out.
      Berkman panned out in 2011, but must have a chronic knee vulnerability that caught up with him again in 2012 on an absurdly routine play at 1B. If he tries to play again in 2013, Lance needs to DH for an AL team. His re-injury risk now seems so high, its going to cut his earning potential.
      The same knee vulnerability could happen with Beltran in 2013, but we will just keep our fingers crossed.

      • blingboy says:

        Linebrink is at the top of my list. He scammed us. Then Feliz, then Fuentes.

        I hope Wiggy does not join them. How much of that two years contract is Mo willing to eat if need be? In my mind, if he makes it through 2014 it means all our hopes and dreams for a real middle infield have gone up in flames.

        It goes without saying, I hope he rebounds and contributes, and I have to eat crow.

        • JumboShrimp says:

          Linebrink was ok for the Braves in 2011. He showed enough in spring training to land a ML contract, then promptly headed to the DL. Springer did that to us the first time, but came back and pitched well during his second association with the Cards.

          Feliz was over the hill and Mo knew it, but we had to do something during August 2010, to try to fool the fans.

          Brian Fuentes was a reasonable signing as a gamble. The As were on the hook to pay most of his salary. Not long ago, Fuentes had good stuff. It was a tribute to Mo that he built on past wooing of Fuentes and was able to land him this time. But Fuentes must have lost his mojo and could not be restored.

          At least Fuentes was accomplished once. I have doubts about Wiggy. But he might work in the niche role versus LHPs. Time will reveal all.

Leave a Reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.